Dylan Lopez
UX case study · Mobile app redesign

Hidden in Plain Sight

Redesigning Slack’s mobile navigation so its most useful features can actually be found.

RoleUX researcher and designer
Timeline3 weeks, Feb–Mar 2024
Team5 students, DSGN 1, UC San Diego
ToolsFigma, FigJam, Google Sheets

An independent student concept, not affiliated with or endorsed by Slack.

01 · The problem

Powerful features nobody can find

Slack packs a lot into its mobile app, but much of it sits behind unlabeled icons and nested menus. A limited color palette makes names and messages hard to tell apart, and there is little guidance on where things live.

Goal: make Slack’s features easier to discover, without adding new ones.

Slack Drafts and Sent screen where testers looked to schedule a message
Where most people looked to schedule a message: Drafts & Sent.
Slack message screen with the Schedule message option in a sheet
Where it actually lives: a sheet opened from the message box.
Slack status menu showing Set yourself as away below the status field
People tapped “Set yourself as away” instead of the status field.
02 · Research

16 interviews, 9 tasks

Our team ran moderated interviews with 16 people who had used Slack at least a little, mostly students and early-career workers using it for jobs and internships. We used the master-apprentice approach: participants worked on their own phones while we watched and recorded. I conducted three of the interviews.

Each person completed nine tasks, from common ones like sending a message to buried ones like scheduling a message or creating a poll, then rated how hard Slack was to navigate.

16participants
4/4common tasks completed by everyone
13/16rated navigation 3 or harder, out of 5

How many of 16 people failed each task

1 · Create a workspace
0
2 · Accept an invite
0
3 · Send a direct message
0
4 · Set a status
0
5 · Find archived messages
10
6 · Schedule a message
8
7 · Find mentioned threads
4
8 · Open Canvas
2
9 · Create a poll
13

Everyone completed tasks 1 to 4. Failures climbed once tasks reached features without clear signifiers.

03 · Findings

People weren’t careless. The signs were missing.

No signifiers

Scheduling a message, for example, lives under “Drafts & Sent,” not in the message box where people looked.

Mental models didn’t match

All 10 people who failed to find archived messages looked in DMs first, assuming it would be there.

Hidden behind commands

Polls and other plugin features sit behind slash commands and extra setup.

“Just feels like a worse version of Discord.”Interviewee, on trying to use plugins

We also mapped Slack against Meta Workplace, Microsoft Teams, Discord and Google Workspace on two design spaces: discoverability against number of features, and usefulness against usability. Slack scored 1.5 out of 5 for both discoverability and usability, the lowest of the five. Our target was the top-right corner: many features, all easy to find.

04 · The redesign

Same features, clearer signs

We worked through three iterations using the Double Diamond process, focusing on the workspace, DMs, activity and profile screens and leaving minor settings alone.

Added a profile button, new colors and new icons, but purple against black was hard to read.

Black and white bar that turns purple when selected, and “Home” renamed “Workspace.”

Purple and white bar with a white bubble around the active tab, giving clear feedback.

Where it started

Early sketches of the workspace, profile and messages screens.

Hand sketch of a workspaces screen
Workspaces
Hand sketch of a profile screen
Profile
Hand sketch of a messages screen
Messages

Clearer structure

Workspaces as a colorful grid, message previews under names in DMs, and a shortcut to pending invites in Activity.

Redesigned workspaces screen with a grid of colored workspace tiles
Workspaces
Redesigned direct messages screen with previews under each name
Direct messages
Redesigned activity and mentions screen with pending invites at the top
Activity and mentions

Features where people look

Archived messages moved to the profile page, since that was where participants went first, and a plugin icon added to the message bar so slash commands are one tap away.

Redesigned profile screen with a View archived messages option
Profile
Redesigned channel screen with icons in the message bar
Channel
05 · Trade-offs and next steps

What I’d do next

Fewer, clearer features

Simplifying the front page may hide some power-user options, a deliberate trade for easier discovery.

Test the redesign

We tested the original Slack, not the redesign. The next step is a round of usability tests with the new design, ideally with a more varied group than students.

Improve accessibility

Check text and icon contrast, and add a light and dark mode.

My part: I helped plan and run interviews and wrote up the redesign iterations and trade-offs. What I learned: when most people fail the same task, the design is the problem, not the user.